Search the Issue Highlights:  

Search Tips

Issue Index About SPR Subscriptions The Author  
 

 

 
     

April, 2007
 

Overview of topics...

LEAD NOTE :

  • "LETTER OF ENGAGEMENT" RULE GETS RELAXED CONSTRUCTION;
    QUANTUM MERUIT RECOVERY FOR LEGAL SERVICES HELD
    ALLOWABLE EVEN IF NO LETTER FURNISHED

SPECIAL NOTE:

  • Service in Special Proceedings: Don't Use Substituted Methods

GENERAL PRACTICE:

  • In Court of Claims Pleading, Failure to Set Forth Total Amount Sought Held Fatal
  • What Constitutes Loss of Index Finger to Qualify as "Grave Injury" and Allow Employer's Impleader?
  • CPLR 3404, Providing for Dismissal of Abandoned Cases, Held Inapplicable in Civil Court
  • Unless Defect Merely Clerical, CPLR 5019(a), the Correction Statute, Can't Be Used to Alter Damages Award; What Can Be?
  • Arons Case, in Which Appellate Division Held Defendant Is Not Entitled to Post-Note of Issue Interview with Plaintiff's Treating Physician, Goes to Court of Appeals

BACKLOG ITEMS:

  • P's Lack of "Standing" Does Not Go to Subject Matter Jurisdiction; D Can Therefore Waive It
  • When Party Is Resident in Foreign Country, Foreign Law Must Be Consulted and Its Disclosure Restrictions Considered
  • Court Treats in Detail Manufacturer's Disclosure Obligations When Product's Design and Manufacture Is at Issue
  • If Attorney's Fees Are Warranted, They Must Be Sought Within the Action
  • Court's Striking of Note of Issue Is Not the Kind of Calendar Striking That Invokes CPLR 3404 and Requires Restoration Within Year
  • Making Motion Returnable on Wednesday When Judge's Motion Day Is Tuesday Does Not Make Motion Untimely
  • Sampling of Appellate Division Cases Finding Good Reason to Excuse Late Summary Judgment Motion
  • Where the Complaint Served on Some Defendants Omitted Names of Several Plaintiffs, But One Named All, Defect Not Jurisdictional

 ARTICLE HEADLINES


Feature Article:

"LETTER OF ENGAGEMENT" RULE GETS RELAXED CONSTRUCTION; QUANTUM MERUIT RECOVERY FOR LEGAL SERVICES HELD ALLOWABLE EVEN IF NO LETTER FURNISHED

Special Note:

SERVICE IN SPECIAL PROCEEDINGS
Stick to Personal Delivery; Substituted
Service Methods Make Trouble

General Practice:

COURT OF CLAIMS PRACTICE
In Personal Injury Case, Failure to Set Forth Total Amount Claimed Held Fatal

WHAT IS "GRAVE INJURY"?
Loss of Two Joints of Index Finger Equals Loss of Index Finger Itself, Permitting Impleader of Employer

DISMISSAL OF ABANDONED CASES
CPLR 3404, Providing for Dismissal of Abandoned Cases, Held Inapplicable in Civil Court

 

 


HIPAA AGAIN
Arons Case, in Which Appellate Division Held Defendant Is Not Entitled to Post-Note of Issue Interview with Plaintiff's Treating Physician, Goes to Court of Appeals

ALTERING DAMAGES AWARD
Unless Defect Merely Clerical, CPLR 5019(a) Can't Be Used to Correct Damages Award; What Can Be?

NOTE: We've been referring to this segment of the Practice Review as "Backlog Items". These have been accruing in such large numbers, however, that there just hasn't been space for all of them. To make space for more, we're going to try to keep each of them especially terse. Also, many busy practitioners, singling out the terser of these "backlog items" over the years, have told us they find them especially helpful. Hence the new caption: BACKLOG SYNOPSES.

Backlog Synopses:

"STANDING" vs. "CAPACITY"
P's Lack of "Standing" Does Not Go to Subject Matter Jurisdiction; D Can Therefore Waive It

DISCLOSURE IN FOREIGN COUNTRY
When Party Is Resident in Foreign Country, Foreign Law Must Be Consulted and Its Disclosure Restrictions Considered

 

 


PRODUCTS LIABILITY
Court Treats in Detail Manufacturer's Disclosure Obligations When Product's Design and Manufacture Is at Issue

ATTORNEY'S FEES
If Attorney's Fees Are Warranted, They Must Be Sought Within the Action

DISTINGUISHING LAXNESS DISMISSALS
Court's Striking of Note of Issue Is Not the Kind of Calendar Striking That Invokes CPLR 3404

MISTAKING JUDGE'S "MOTION DAYS"
Making Motion Returnable on Wednesday When Judge's Motion Day Is Tuesday Does Not Make Motion Untimely

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Sampling of Appellate Division Cases Finding Good Reason to Excuse Late Motion

OMITTING PLAINTIFFS' NAMES
Where the Complaint Served on Some Defendants Omitted Names of Several Plaintiffs, But One Named All, Defect Not Jurisdictional

 

         
  ©1993 David D. Siegel  All rights reserved.   |   Web design & hosting by Azurelink.   |  Site Comments?