Search the Issue Highlights:  

Search Tips

Issue Index About SPR Subscriptions The Author  
 

 

 
     

JUNE 1998
 
Overview of topics...

Lead Note:

THE MANY WAYS IN WHICH A PLAINTIFF PAYS FOR FAILING TO JOIN, INADVERTENTLY OR INTENTIONALLY, ALL POSSIBLE TORTFEASORS

Tracking the New Laws:

 

  • Dole Case Not Overruled
  • App. Div. Says New CPLR 306-b Can't Revive Previously "Deemed Dismissed" Cases

General Practice:

 

  • Different Departmental Attitudes on Expert Disclosure
  • In Med Mal Case, Name Even of Examining Physician Can Be Withheld
  • D Loses Rights Against Co-D by Not Opposing Co-D's Summary Judgment Motion Against P
  • D's Allowing Destruction of Evidence Before Impleading Manufacturer Forfeits Impleader Claim

Backlog Items:

 

  • When Can Opponent's Expert Be Deposed?
  • Frivolous Liability Defense Brings $10,000 Sanction Against Defendant's Lawyer
  • Proper Procedure for Commencing Action Against Unknown Party

Federal Practice:

 

  • Only State Method Adopted for Federal Summons Service, Not Incidents (Like Answering Time)
  • N.Y. Substituted Service Methods Okay Even for Service of Federal Subpoena

Open Citations:

 

  • Achampong (Issue 61:Page 4): 240 A.D.2d 247.
  • Sullivan (63:4): 175 Misc.2d 386, 669 N.Y.S.2d 131 (Oct. 7, 1997).

 ARTICLE HEADLINES

FEATURE ARTICLE:
THE MANY WAYS IN WHICH A PLAINTIFF PAYS FOR FAILING TO JOIN, INADVERTENTLY OR INTENTIONALLY, ALL POSSIBLE TORTFEASORS

 TRACKING THE NEW LAWS

"OMNIBUS" ACT ADDRESSED:
Clarification of Court of Appeals Statement That Legislature Intended to "Repeal" Dole Case

CPLR 306-b NOT RETROACTIVE:
First Department Holds That New Statute Abolishing Automatic "Deemed" Dismissal Is Not Retroactive

 GENERAL PRACTICE

EXPERT DISCLOSURE IN GENERAL:
Differences Between Departments Pointed Up on Practice Involving Expert Disclosure

 
EXPERT DISCLOSURE IN MED MAL CASE:
Even Report of Examining Physician Can Omit Identifying Features If Physician Will Also Be Expert Witness

ARTICLE 16:
Defendant Who Would Preserve Article 16 Rights Against Co-Defendant Must Respond to Summary Judgment Motion

SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE:
D's Allowing Destruction of Physical Evidence Brings Dismissal of Its Impleader Claim
 BACKLOG ITEMS

ORAL DEPOSITION OF EXPERT?:
Review of When Oral Deposition of Expert May Be Allowed

 
FRIVOLOUS LIABILITY DEFENSE:
Frivolity Sanction Imposed Against Defendant for Insisting on Liability Trial With No Proof to Offer

PROPER PROCEDURE FOR SUING UNKNOWN PARTIES AND AVOIDING STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS PROBLEMS; PLAINTIFF MUST ACT FAST

 FEDERAL PRACTICE

USING N.Y.'S SERVICE METHODS:
When N.Y. Substituted Service Is Used in Federal Court, Only Method Is Adopted, Not Answering Time or Proof of Service Items

FEDERAL SUBPOENA SERVICE:
State Methods Also Apply to Federal Subpoena, So State Substituted Service Is Available for Subpoenas, Too

         
  ©1993 David D. Siegel  All rights reserved.   |   Web design & hosting by Azurelink.   |  Site Comments?