Search the Issue Highlights:  

Search Tips

Issue Index About SPR Subscriptions The Author  
 

 

 
     

NOVEMBER EXTRA 1997
 
Overview of topics...

Lead Note:

"DEEMED DISMISSED" FEATURE OF FILING SYSTEM ABOLISHED; COURT GIVEN DISCRETION TO EXTEND TIME FOR SERVICE-- PART V

General Practice:

 

  • After Motion to Dismiss Fails, Answer in Special Proceeding Is Not Matter of Right
  • Territorial Scope of Subpoena Being Used in Judgment Enforcement:
       - Information Subpoena
       - Ordinary Testimonial Subpoena
  • When Is Affidavit of Non-Military Service Required?
  • Appealing Only Part of Order Forfeits Review of Remainder

Backlog Items:

 

  • For Sanction for Discovery Misconduct, Frivolity Showing Not Necessary
  • Lower Courts' Money Cap, Inapplicable to Counterclaim, Applies to Cross-Claim

Open Citations:

 

  • Bensusan (Issue 62:Page 3): 126 F.3d (not F.2d) 25.

 ARTICLE HEADLINES


NOTE ON COVERAGE OF AMENDED SANCTIONS RULE

FEATURE ARTICLE:
"DEEMED DISMISSED" FEATURE OF FILING SYSTEM ABOLISHED; COURT GIVEN DISCRETION TO EXTEND TIME FOR SERVICE-- PART V

 

  • Extension Motion Best Made During the 120 Days
  • Motion to Extend Made Ex Parte; Appellate Issues
  • Effect of Differences in Appealability Between Federal and New York Law
  • No Sua Sponte Dismissal, in Contrast with Federal Practice
  • Abolition of Plaintiff's 120-Day Period for Suit After Dismissal for Improper Service

 
 GENERAL PRACTICE

ANSWER IN SPECIAL PROCEEDING:
Unlike Action, In Special Proceeding There's No "Right" to Answer After Motion to Dismiss Is Denied

SUBPOENA SERVICE:
Okay to Serve Information Subpoena on Defendant Outside State

IMMUNITY RE SUBPOENA SERVICE:
Service of Ordinary Subpoena on Judgment Debtor in New York to Testify on Unrelated Matter Is Upheld on Special Facts

AFFIDAVIT OF NON-MILITARY SERVICE:
Affidavit That Defendant Is Not in Military Service Required Only in Default Cases

 
APPEALING AN ORDER:
Can't Cure Failure to Include Item in Appeal from Order by Moving to Amend Notice of Appeal

 BACKLOG ITEMS

DISCLOSURE SANCTIONS:
For Disclosure Sanctions, Conduct Need Not Rise to "Frivolous" Level

CAP ON LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
While Lower Courts' Jurisdiction of Money Counterclaims Is Unlimited, the Usual Cap Applies to Cross-Claims

         
  ©1993 David D. Siegel  All rights reserved.   |   Web design & hosting by Azurelink.   |  Site Comments?